Thursday, 3 September 2009

Who hates whom the mostest? (aka: better be an atheist...)

Over at Planck’s Constant Blog, fellow grey-beard Bernie has come up with a “Muslim Threat Index”.  Good one, Bernie!
No surprises in Pakistan being at the top of the danger league, though perhaps surprising that it’s by such a large margin a greater potential threat than the next on the list Nigeria.  I was also surprised – though perhaps fellow Aussies may not be – by Indonesia’s being so high on the threat list.
I can hear all the criticisms of this “Threat Index”, from “you can’t be serious” to “it’s not nuanced enough” and so forth.  My view: it’s been done with enough care and with enough factors to make it a useful reference.  No doubt it can be improved (“nuanced”) but meantime it’s useful and I commend it, even unto the “government security agencies”…. I know about them from times past and their threat assessments were often nuanced to pabulum…
I’ve just done my own Index: the “Discrimination Index”, aka the “Victimhood Index”.  It came about because of the claims we hear from Muslim spokespersons whenever there’s some outrage committed by their co-religionists, that they fear a “backlash” against Muslims. Some of the more egregious examples are: after the Mumbai bombing and the murder of the Jewish leader and his pregnant wife, what we heard from Muslim commentators was concern for the safety of Muslims.  And most recently, the Rifqa Bary case, about which I wrote here.  There is less concern for Ms Bary’s safety than for the alleged backlash against Muslims that the publicity of the case might entail.
So, is it true that Muslims are discriminated against disproportionately to their numbers in society?  To calculate that I got the numbers of Hate Crimes in the US against each religion, and the percentage of those religions in the total population (refs below).  Divide hate crime per religion by that religion’s percentage in the population:  if the answer is 1 (one), then that religion is experiencing hate crime in proportion to its share of the population.  A figure higher than 1 (one) means they’re being disproportionately targeted by hate crimes.
These are the results:
Crimes against:
% of crimes
% of population
Discrimination Index
Jews
69.2%
1.2%
57.67
Muslims
8.7%
0.6%
14.50
Catholics
4.3%
25.0%
0.17
Protestants
4.1%
51.0%
0.08
Atheists
0.5%
15.0%
0.03
Other
9.1%
8.0%
1.14
            [Total "Hate Crimes" in 2007: 9,567] 
So: yes, Muslims are disproportionately targeted while we Atheists get off almost scot-free.  But way more discriminated against are the Jews, by a factor of 57 versus the base of 1 (one) and four times more than Muslims are.  I know there are anti-anti-Semitism lobby groups; but we do not hear from them nearly so often as we do from the Muslim ones.  Why is that?  Given that they are way more disproportionately targeted? 
What is surprising perhaps, given their co-religionists insistence on attempting to kill infidels, is that the number of hate crimes against Muslims is actually so low: just 141 in 2007.  (and btw, Daniel Pipes has shown elsewhere that many of the crimes against Muslims were “manufactured” by the Muslim bodies such as CAIR; but we’ll leave that for the moment).
Another interesting point: the fastest growing belief 1990 to 2008 was Atheism.  Islam was fifth fastest growing, after Atheism, Buddhism, Born-again Christians, and non-denominational Christians.  Interesting, when we hear so often from Islamic sources, that Islam is the fastest growing religion.
And what about the total number?  According to the stats, the number of Muslims in the US is 1.8 million.  That’s way less than Muslim lobby groups quote: most often they say 5 to 7 million Muslims in the US.  Hmm….. the less the size of the group, the less is your clout.  I wonder why they exaggerate by nearly 300%...
US population
305,000,000
2008/1990 Growth
Jews
3,660,000
14.6%
Muslims
1,830,000
156.0%
Catholics
76,250,000
24.3%
Protestants
155,550,000
10.4%
Atheists
45,750,000
204.0%
Other religions
24,400,000
0 to 300%
References:
1.    FBI Hate Crime Statistics, 2007, from the Uniform Crime Reporting Progam, FBI, 2008.
2.   Demographics: Statistics of Religion in the US from the American Religious Identification Survey, 2008, and on the Population, from the US Census Department, Feb 2009.

Shane the Aussie Jihadist -- out of jail by May '10

There are broadly two streams of thought as to what causes Islamic terrorism. 
(1) Is the “Islam has a grievance” stream of thought (let’s be done with it, and call it a “narrative”). 
(2)“Islam seeks world caliphate” narrative. 
Most of the US Administration from George W. Bush to Obama believe in the first narrative: Islam has grievances.  These “grievances” are the usual suspects: colonialism, imperialism, US policy in the middle east, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, Israel-Palestine, lack of respect for Islam and so forth.  If we fix these, we shall be at peace with the Muslim world.  It was this thought that wove through Obama’s speech to Muslims in June.
The second stream says that the driving force of Islamic terrorism is the desire to bring Islam – by force if necessary – to the rest of the world, by global Jihad, to institute an Islamic caliphate according to Sharia law. 
Clearly the latter does not exclude the former.  If you believe that this narrative – the Islam seeks world dominance narrative – is true, then the way you deal with Islamic terrorism will be very different, for you will recognize that concessions to the “grievances” can only be short-term solutions at best.
The story below illustrates that both narratives are driving the Aussie Jihadist Shane Kent, though I bet most commentators will focus on the “grievance side” of his motivation  -- “to force the Federal Government to withdraw from Iraq and Afghanistan” – and ignore that latter  –“violence against the kuffar”.  Know thy enemy, they all say.  But not too well…  or so it appears.
A HOME-GROWN terrorist who was part of a group that planned attacks in Melbourne could be free in just over nine months.
After pleading guilty to being part of a terrorist group Shane Kent, 32, [tha’s him in his jihadi clobber above] was jailed for a minimum term of three years and nine months.
Justice Bernard Bongiorno set a maximum term of five years after saying Kent had not abandoned his violent jihadist views.
The Supreme Court judge also said Kent was not genuinely sorry for his part in the terror group.
He said the group or 'jemaah' planned their terrorist activities to force the Federal Government to withdraw troops from Iraq and Afghanistan.
This is  the “Islam has grievances” narrative.
Kent was an enthusiastic member and he and the others were secretly recorded talking about jihad and the promotion of the Islamic cause by violence against the kuffar - Arabic for unbelievers.
This is the “Islam seeks a caliphate” narrative.
"On each of these conversations, as in many others, he (Kent) spoke as a member of the group and not as an outsider," Justice Bongiorno said.
They talked of members of the "jemaah" needing to be ready to destroy buildings and kill people in a jihad.
"The actions of those who engaged in the 11 September 2001 attacks in the United States and the attacks on trains in Madrid and London were discussed in terms of praise and admiration," the judge said.
Kent, a father of three of Meadow Heights, could be out in just over nine months as he has served 1115 days on remand.
Justice Bongiorno said that Kent had a psychiatric disorder and psychiatrists had said he was remorseful.
"He is doubtless sorry for having imposed the hardship of his incarceration on his family," the judge said.
"However, I am not prepared to accept . . . that he has abandoned the cause of violent jihad."
Kent pleaded guilty to being a member of a terrorist group between 1 July 2004 and 8 November 2005 and of recklessly making a document connected with preparation for a terrorist act.
He admitted helping create an Islamic propaganda jihadist video featuring Osama bin Laden, tributes to "martyrs" and a graphic image of a dead young extremist.
Postscript: I wrote here about other Aussie Jihadis and why it’s not just a “small minority” of extremists.  And here, about the al-Qaeda view of the infidel west:
“In fact, Muslims are obligated to raid the lands of the infidels, occupy them and exchange their systems of governance for an Islamic system, barring any practice that contradicts the Sharia from being publicly voiced among the people…”.
--- (The Al Qaeda Reader, p.51)

Wednesday, 2 September 2009

Ahmadinejad's Imam: Islam Allows Raping, Torturing Prisoners

Posting this one in full, shocking as it is....(link here ):
There's no moral equivalence between the rape-torture described here and CIA actions such as firing guns next door, sleep deprivation, and so forth.

[At right: the Ayatollah and Ahmadinejad study Playboy ...and the finer points of Islamically "permissable"rape?]
---------

(IsraelNN.com) A highly influential Shi'a religious leader, with whom Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad regularly consults, apparently told followers last month that coercion by means of rape, torture and drugs is acceptable against all opponents of the Islamic regime.
Warning: The imam's question-and-answer session, partially reproduced here, contains disturbing descriptions of the sanctioned brutality.
In the wake of a series of publications worldwide regarding the rape and torture of dissident prisoners in Iran's jails, supporters of Ahmadinejad gathered with him in Jamkaran, a popular pilgrimage site for Shi'ite Muslims on the outskirts of Qom, on August 11, 2009. According to Iranian pro-democracy sources, the gathered crowd heard from Ayatollah Mohammad Taqi Mesbah-Yazdi and Ahmadinejad himself regarding the issue.
According to the Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center (ITIC), an independent Israeli intelligence analysis organization, Mesbah-Yazdi is considered Ahmadinejad's personal spiritual guide. A radical totalitarian even in Iranian terms, he holds messianic views, supports increasing Islamization, calls for violent suppression of domestic political opponents, and, according to the ITIC, "declared that obeying a president supported by the Supreme Leader was tantamount to obeying God."
At the Jamkaran gathering, Mesbah-Yazdi and Ahmadinejad answered questions about the rape and torture charges. The following text is from a transcript alleged by Iranian dissidents to be a series of questions and answers exchanged between the ayatollah and some of his supporters.
Asked if a confession obtained "by applying psychological, emotional and physical pressure" was "valid and considered credible according to Islam," Mesbah-Yazdi replied: "Getting a confession from any person who is against the Velayat-e Faqih ("Guardianship of the Islamic Jurists", or the regime of Iran's mullahs) is permissible under any condition." The ayatollah gave the identical answer when asked about confessions obtained through drugging the prisoner with opiates or addictive substances.
"Can an interrogator rape the prisoner in order to obtain a confession?" was the follow-up question posed to the Islamic cleric.
Mesbah-Yazdi answered: "The necessary precaution is for the interrogator to perform a ritual washing first and say prayers while raping the prisoner. If the prisoner is female, it is permissible to rape through the vagina or anus. It is better not to have a witness present. If it is a male prisoner, then it's acceptable for someone else to watch while the rape is committed."
This reply, and reports of the rape of teen male prisoners in Iranian jails, may have prompted the following question: "Is the rape of men and young boys considered sodomy?"
Ayatollah Mesbah-Yazdi: "No, because it is not consensual. Of course, if the prisoner is aroused and enjoys the rape, then caution must be taken not to repeat the rape."
A related issue, in the eyes of the questioners, was the rape of virgin female prisoners. In this instance, Mesbah-Yazdi went beyond the permissibility issue and described the Allah-sanctioned rewards accorded the rapist-in-the-name-of-Islam:
"If the judgment for the [female] prisoner is execution, then rape before execution brings the interrogator a spiritual reward equivalent to making the mandated Haj pilgrimage [to Mecca], but if there is no execution decreed, then the reward would be equivalent to making a pilgrimage to [the Shi'ite holy city of] Karbala."
One aspect of these permitted rapes troubled certain questioners: "What if the female prisoner gets pregnant? Is the child considered illegitimate?"
Mesbah-Yazdi answered: "The child borne to any weakling [a denigrating term for women - ed.] who is against the Supreme Leader is considered illegitimate, be it a result of rape by her interrogator or through intercourse with her husband, according to the written word in the Koran. However, if the child is raised by the jailer, then the child is considered a legitimate Shi'a Muslim." 

Tuesday, 1 September 2009

Can Banna the Younger right the wrongs of Banna the Elder?

What do an 88-year old Egyptian writer living in Cairo and a teenage American girl living in Florida have in common?

Answer: the Muslim Brotherhood, Islamic Jihad and “honour killings”.

Here are the dots….

Gamal al-Banna is the 88-year old Egyptian writer, the younger brother of the late Hassan al-Banna.
Banna the Elder established the Muslim Brotherhood in 1928. 
The Muslim Brotherhood’s influence was greatly expanded by Sayyid Qutb in the 1950s (that's Qutb pictured here).
Qutb was mentor to Osama bin Laden and to Ayman Zawahiri, a “theoretician” of al-Qaeda.  Much of the terror rhetoric of al-Qaeda draws directly from the Muslim Brotherhood.  In the US, the Muslim Brotherhood has said that it is engaged, in its own words:
"... in a kind of grand Jihad in eliminating and destroying the Western civilization from within and sabotaging its miserable house by their hands and the hands of the believers so that it is eliminated and God's religion is made victorious over all other religions."
The Muslim Brotherhood motto:
"Allah is our objective. The Prophet is our leader. The Qur'an is our law. Jihad is our way. Dying in the way of Allah is our highest hope."
The Muslim Brotherhood platform demands strict implementation of Sharia law, which calls for death for apostasy, including killing one’s children:
“When a person … apostatizes from Islam, he deserves to be killed”  (Manual of Islamic Jurisprudence, Reliance of the Traveller,  o.8.1).  And:
“The following are not subject to retaliation: …  a father or mother for killing their offspring, or offspring’s offspring” (o.1.2)
This is not just Islamic legal theory.  It is also fact. People are killed, tortured, raped or threatened with death all the time for apostasy from Islam [Ref 4].
“You get the picture?  Oh yes, we see….
Hassan and Sayyid,
the leaders of the pack…”
Banna the Younger writes for a more moderate Islam: he’s against the wearing of the veil, against female genital mutilation, in favour of women leading prayer.
The teenage American girl is Rifqa Bary, the 17-year old from Ohio who converted from Islam to Christianity in 2005, and about whom I wrote here .   When her father found out she had become an apostate from Islam, she says he beat her and threatened to kill her.  She fled to Florida in July, in fear for her life.
The Muslim Brotherhood connection?  The lawyers for Ms Bary have issued to the media an “Investigation and Intelligence Memorandum” [3] which provides evidence from the US Justice Department of connections between the Noor Mosque in Ohio attended by the Bary family and the Muslim Brotherhood, and Hamas, and Jihadi terrorism.
Since (a) the Muslim Brotherhood is an Islamist organisation calling for for strict adherence to Sharia, which mandates death for apostates, since (b) the Noor Mosque has clear connections to the Muslim Brotherhood and since (c) Mr. Bary was a devoted attendee at the Noor Mosque, there is at least clear a priori evidence to keep Ms Bary away from her father.
You would think that the “moderate Muslims” we hear so much about would tackle this issue: try to get the death penalty for apostasy provisions changed.  But the problem is, they can’t.  There can be no change in Islam and Islamic law: Ijtihad (Koranic and Hadithian exegesis) closed its door centuries ago.
So all they can do is try to deny that death provisions exist (in which they are plain wrong), and try to shift the focus from the threat on the young girl’s life, by instead raising fears for their own safety!  Robert Spencer:
“This is, of course, how Islamic groups in the U.S. have reacted to every act of violence and every threat that any Muslim has issued in recent years: they've raised fears of a non-existent "backlash" and claimed they're being persecuted, rather than address the root causes of the violence and brutality within their own community. And the bemused, befuddled multiculturalists in the mainstream media go along with it happily, every time.” (ref)
In his latest article in favour of some flexibility [2] in Islam Banna the Younger has said that belly dancers ought not to be criticized. 
Would it not be nice if this old Lion of Moderation were able to address the Rifqa Bary case direct? A nice kind of squaring of the circle.  To denounce honour killings, flat out, no if’s no buts.  And denounce, while he’s about it, the poisonous legacy of his brother’s most famous creation the Muslim Brotherhood.
BTW: I’ve read Sayyid Qutb: his Milestones and Social Justice in Islam.  They’re pretty dreary, illogical, circular in argumentation, frequently self-contradictory, and otherwise a farrago of sophistry.  I thought them rather like reading Mao Tse-tung in the seventies, when I had to do it at the Peking Language Institute: writing that was like fairy floss, fluffy and insubstantial, superficially pretty, but squashing down to nothing, sickly sweet glob.   Both writers, Qutb and Mao, have caused rather a lot of trouble,  though, thereby proving Orwell right: that we have to watch out for bad writing, as it can have baleful effects.  In particular we need to watch Qutb and the Muslim Brotherhood; unlike Mao, they continue to pursue their aims for a worse world.
References:
   1.   A voice for 'new understanding' of Islam -  Michael Slackman discusses Gamal al-Banna, IHT 20 Oct 2006,
   2.   Hints of Pluralism in Egyptian Religious Debates, Michael Slackman on Gamal al-Banna, IHT, 1 September 2009
   3.    Investigation and Intelligence Memorandum,  Issued in Rifqa Bary case, 30th August 2009
   4.   Murders, torture, rape or death threats for apostasy from Islam in: Australia, Bangladesh,  Britain, Britain again, Egypt, Egypt again, Iran, Nigeria, Somalia

Monday, 31 August 2009

Should Rifqa be sent back to Ohio?

The case of a young girl called Rifqa Bary has been much in the media.  Should she be sent back to Ohio?  There are some who say that no matter what you've done, being sent to Ohio would constitute "cruel and unusual punishment".  Hmmm..... anyway, should she be sent back home to her family?  You decide….
She’s a 17 year old from Ohio, her parents from Sri Lanka, came to the US about 10 years ago.  Rifqa converted to Christianity four years ago, without telling her Sunni parents.  When the father found out, he threatened to kill her (says Rifqa: because of the Islamic laws on apostasy) and so she ran away to Florida, and is now in the care of a Christian group.  The father wants her back, says he loves her and she can follow any religion she wants. 
Public concern was voiced.  The Florida governor ruled that she is to stay in Florida until an investigation can be made into the family’s circumstances.
Muslim and some non-Muslim commentators say she should be sent back to her family. Others say she should be left where she’s safe from the possibility of another “honour killing” at the hands of her male relatives.
What’s fair to say:
For now, it’s still a “she says, he says” situation.
What’s not fair to say:
That the father has “good will” (the Ohio police) and that he’s “not a fundamentalist” (Salam al-Marayati, refs below).  How do they know?  If they’re wrong, the penalty is Rifqa’s life.
It seems to me that while there’s any doubt, she has to stay where she is.
Meantime, the case has raised –  yet again –  the issue of apostasy in Islam and the penalty for it.  There is no death penalty for apostasy says al-Marayati.  “no it’s not [in the Koran], sweet little Rifqa”, says al-Marayati. "...sweet little Rifqa" (!!).  shudder... and ... ugh….
Al-Marayati is plain wrong.   The penalty for apostasy in Sunni Islam is death.  Many commentators on the Huffington site have pointed this out.  I would add the mandate from the Classic Manual of Islamic law the ‘Umdat al-Salik, o.8.1:
“When a person … apostatizes from Islam, he deserves to be killed”. 
And apostates have been killed, most recently and most often in Pakistan.   Islam is the only religion that had and still has laws mandating the death for those who wish to leave it.
Interestingly, the comments on the Huffingon Post, which is a left-of-centre site, are solidly against the tenor of al-Marayati’s piece and point out the juridical and religious grounds for the death penalty for apostasy in Islam. 
References:
1.    Rifqa Bary.   YouTube, 11 August 09.
4.    Rifqa, the Reverand [sic] and Apostasy,  Salam al-Marayati, Huffington Post, 18 August 2009
3.    Anti-Muslim bias in Fathima Rifqa Bary case.  Mike Thomas, Orlando Sentinel, 23 August 2009
4.    Media Distort Facts of Threatened Muslim Girl Story, Pamela Geller, Newsmax, 24 August 2009
5.    “Apostasy” and Wafa Sultan’s exchange….  Andrew Bostom, JihadWatch, 30 August 2009.

Friday, 28 August 2009

What Sharia says about charity.... (or, alms for arms?)

My wife has been onto me recently: “you’re always banging on about the negative side of Islam.  Surely there’s some positives”.
So I took her up and started a re-read of the Koran, looking for positives:  and I found one!   Or did I?...  The Koran calls for the giving of alms, zakat.   How this is given in practice is defined in the Umdat al-Salik, ("Reliance of the Traveller").  Read on, for more on Zakat, the Islamic giving of alms...
What is Zakat?: it means “growth, blessings, an increase in good, purifications or praise” (h1.0.  Sources: see bottom of post*)
Who must pay Zakat?: all free Muslims (h1.1).  Apostates need not pay because “their property is considered to belong to the Muslim common fund from the moment such people leave Islam.” (h1.2, emphasis in the original).  This is because as apostates, they will have been killed (o8.1).
How much is Zakat?:  2.5% (h4.0 et. seq.).  The percentage is a bit different if your wealth is goats or camels, in which case discuss with your investment adviser.
To whom must Zakat be given?:  Most importantly it can only be given to Muslims (h8.7 et. seq.).   This law is derived from the Koran, 9.60 “Alms are only for … those whose hearts are made to incline to Truth (i.e. to Islam)… and in the way of Allah.”  The meaning and intent of the word “Zakat” is therefore materially different from the western concept of “charity”.
There are eight – and only eight -- categories of authorized recipients of Zakat (h8.8-18):
1.  The poor2.  Those short of money3.  Zakat “workers”: i.e. charitable agencies4.  Those “whose hearts are to be reconciled”: such as new converts to Islam. But specifically not non-Muslims.5.  Those purchasing their freedom (i.e. slaves)6.  Those in debt  7.  "Those fighting for Allah, meaning people engaged in Islamic military operations for whom no salary has been allotted in the army roster, but who are volunteers without remuneration” (h8.17.  Emphasis in the original).  PF note: this is why Hamas pays salaries to the families of “martyrs”. 8.  The traveller in need of money (Muslims only).
In all but the Hanbali legal school, the amount of Zakat that one gives shall be divided equally between all eight categories.  That is 12.5% each.  That means that by Islamic law, 12.5% of Zakat will go to those engaged in offensive Jihad.  
Note re category 7: Wikipedia simply says “in the way of Allah” (ref).  The Sunni Law according to the 'Umdat is much more direct: “those fighting for Allah” and in case we miss the point: “in Islamic military operations….”.  In short, fighting Jihad.
Muslim charities, have been in the news recently. Muslim organisations and the American Civil Liberties Union claim that Islamic charities are being unfairly targeted for investigation by US authorities.
Given that (a) all Muslims must give Zakat; that (b) Zakat can be given only to Muslims; and that (c) by law at least 12.5% of Zakat must go to military Jihadi operations, there an a priori case for close scrutiny of all Islamic charity groups. In practice we know that Zakat has gone to Jihadi organisations.
****************
* References with letter/number (eg, h8.17) are from the ‘Umdat al-Salik (Reliance of the Traveller), the Classic Manual of Islamic Sacred Law.  See here.

Thursday, 27 August 2009

Water, water, waste away

I've upset the greenies in my family by coming out against "organic" food as being a big con.  But here's one that should please them: stop using bottled water!

  • 28 billion plastic bottles per year
  • 86% end up as garbage
  • 1500 per second
  • Cost $US 100 billion per year
  • and create 2.5 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide

And the crazy thing: where most of us live, tap water is fine.

(See if you can find mistakes in the pps; there are at least two internally inconsistent numbers; they don't detract from the message, but still....)

Wednesday, 26 August 2009

"The book I just couldn't put down". Free speech alert!

 (Brief background: Author Sebastian Faulks was interviewed about his new book, A Week in December, in the UK’s Telegraph.  He made some fairly tart remarks about the Koran and Muhammad.  Amongst other things, he said that Muhammad could be considered to have been schizophrenic, given that he heard voices in his head (true!).  Two days later, the Telegraph has pulled the original interview and Faulks is in the Telegraph again, this time with a full column of apologia, all of a sudden finding great merit in the Koran, and Muhammad a model of leadership.)
PF Letter to the Sebastian Faulks website:
Like many others, I was disturbed to see the apology by Mr. Faulks to the allegedly upset and offended Muslims....  I happened to agree with pretty much all of what he said in his original article, [pulled from the Telegraph, and only available here].  the one in which he robustly characterised the Koran as “very one dimensional”, “a depressing book”, and about Muhammad, said:  “Muhammad had nothing to say to the world other than, 'If you don't believe in God you will burn forever.’”
These are demonstrably true statements (at least, they are the conclusions of a reasonable, sane and analytical mind on reading the source work).
What on earth possessed Mr. Faulks to issue the craven apology for upsetting the over-delicate sensitivities of some Muslims?  Who — which Muslim organisation -- was it that scared him into the retraction of his views expressed so robustly, into apology, into “humility”, into “plenty of respect”?
On a proposed meeting with Ajmal Masroor, spokesman of the Islamic Council for Britain, why does Mr. Faulks think it necessary to “navigate” by a “cultural compass” of Mr. Masroor’s Islam, rather than expect Mr. Masroor to navigate by the prevailing cultural compass of the surrounding, British, culture?  To take the metaphor a bit further, navigating by two compasses, if they read differently — as one assumes from the context they will -- is surely a recipe for getting well and truly lost.
Why does Mr. Faulks say “I would enter any such dialogue with a degree of humility and
plenty of respect for his religion and his scripture” (my emphasis).  Isn’t it enough to approach such a meeting with sincerity and an open mind.  (“humility”? “respect”?? and “plenty” of it?? gild that lily, sir !..).

Tuesday, 25 August 2009

BBC reads out part of my letter...

BBC Radio just read out on air the first bit of my letter, in full here.  (I was never expecting they would read it in full; just that some of it might be read by BBC editors and inform future coverage).
They also read out -- for balance, of course! --  a comment from someone else saying Scheuer's views were "a breath of fresh air", which only goes to show how little attention and research people do into these issues.  I guess people have jobs....  
They're pretty big issues, one might add, when they revolve around whether giving in to alleged Islamic grievances such as Palestine, the "US occupation of Arabia", and so forth, will be sufficient to have us coexisting peacefully with Islam (as Scheuer maintains), or whether the likes of al-Qaeda have broader aims, such as full Islamic suzerainty over the world via imposition of the Sharia -- as is the demonstrable case, as I point out below.
I'm still hoping the Beebs might take up my suggestion to have Raymond Ibrahim on the show to counter Scheuer's dangerous and disingenuous views.

If we give away Israel, all will be ok.... (not)

Michael Scheuer claims on BBC Radio International (675 AM Hong Kong) that there is no "corpus of rhetoric" to show that Osama bin Laden “hates the West’s liberty, freedom or our way of life”.   If we address Islamic grievances (Palestine, Iraq war, abandon Israel, and so forth) we shall be able to coexist in peace.

In this he is demonstrably wrong.  Worse: he is willfully –and therefore deceitfully – wrong for he knows that such writings exist.

Demonstrably wrong:

In bin Laden’s essay of May 2002, directed at Saudi sheiks (that is, for Islamic-eyes only), titled “Moderate Islam is a Prostration to the West”1, bin Laden says:

On freedom, liberty and the West’s way of life:
“For practically everything valued by the immoral West is condemned under Sharia law.” (p.37)

On coexistence:
“Does Islam or does it not, force people by the power of the sword to submit to its authority corporeally if not spiritually?  Yes.  There are only three choices in Islam; either willing submission; or payment of the jizya [tax on non-Muslims]…; or the sword – for it is not right to let the infidel live.  The matter is summed up for every person alive: Either submit, or live under the suzerainty of Islam; or die”.  (p.42)

In case we miss the point: 
“In fact, Muslims are obligated to raid the lands of the infidels, occupy them and exchange their systems of governance for an Islamic system, barring any practice that contradicts the Sharia from being publicly voiced among the people…”. (p.51)

These are clear and unequivocal statements by al-Qaeda, and there are many, many more, authorized or written by bin Laden or Ayman al-Zawahiri.  Why does Mr. Scheuer say they “don’t exist”??

Willfully wrong: it would be one thing if Scheuer were ignorant of bin Laden’s writings.  But he is not, as evidenced by the debate, in late 2008, with Raymond Ibrahim here. Scheuer says Ibrahim has been “selective”.  Well, of course one has to be selective in any “Reader”….   But, as Ibrahim points out, the Reader quotes writings and speeches from al-Qaeda which are directed both at the Muslim world and those directed at the West.  In any case, whatever the selectivity, to say that there is no evidence of al-Qaeda hating the West’s freedoms (“hating our MacDonalds” as Scheuer cutely puts it), is clearly false and it is equally clear that Scheuer knows of these writings.

This is too  important a topic to leave the last word to Scheuer and his deceit.  As Scheuer himself says, it’s a matter of “knowing one’s enemy”.  Are al-Qaeda after settling grievances (Palestine, the Iraq and Afghani wars, etc), or are they after world domination of Islamic Sharia?  Clearly the former does not preclude the latter.  And clearly the latter – suzerainty of Islamic Sharia – is of overarching importance to al-Qaeda and their fellow travellers.  To say that it’s only the former (Islamic grievances), as does Scheuer and to ignore the latter (Islamic suzerainty) is surely propagating a dangerous misconception.

I urge the BBC to invite Raymond Ibrahim to put the case that the world view of bin Laden and his cronies includes world-wide Islamic caliphate, under Sharia law.

1. The Al Qaeda Reader,  Raymond Ibrahim, Doubleday, NY, 2007, p.22 et. seq.

Monday, 24 August 2009

Hit 'em, but please don't starve 'em; that's un-Islamic!

There’s been a lot in the MSM about a new Afghani law that allows the marital rape of women and punishing them by beating or starving them if they refuse sex. Some commentators have said the law is (i) against the Constitution of Afghanistan, or (ii) it’s not Islamic.
What are the facts?
The Afghanistan Constitution Article 3 states:
“In Afghanistan, no law can be contrary to the beliefs and provisions of the sacred religion of Islam.”
In other words, “provisions of the sacred religion of Islam” are paramount even over the Constitution.  That is, Sharia trumps the Constitution.
What does Sharia law say about this issue?  I turn to my trusty bedside companion: Umdat al-Salik (Reliance of the Traveller), the “Classic Manual of Islamic Sacred Law”.  The Umdat is authorized, inter alia, by Al-Azhar University, the oldest university in the Islamic world and the chief centre of Sunni Islamic learning (also the co-sponsor of Obama’s recent speech to the Muslim world).
What does the Umdat say:
“m5.1:  It is obligatory for a woman to let her husband have sex with her immediately when he asks her.”
“w45.1    A woman is not obliged to serve her husband by baking, grinding flour, cooking, washing, or any other kind of service, because the marriage contract entails for her part, only that she let him enjoy her sexually and she is not obligated to do other than that”.  
Got that?  No need for her to bake a cake or grind his flour, but if he wants to put sausage in her cooker, or grind her flower, he has the right to do that, whenever he wants.
What of punishment if she refuses?   The rules don’t beat about the bush here; for those of us used to bemoaning political correctness in public discourse, there’s a refreshing frankness in the title of this provision:
“m10.11 DEALING WITH A REBELLIOUS WIFE
“m10.12  When a husband notices a sign of rebelliousness in his wife… or he asks her to come to bed and she refuses… he warns her in words…. If she commits rebelliousness he… may hit her, but not in any way that injures her, meaning he may not break bones, wound her or cause blood to flow.  He may hit her whether she is rebellious only once or whether more than once…”. [emphasis in the original]
So, there you have it.  Clear rulings.  No mention there of starving the woman.  Just hitting her.   Got that guys: it’s ok to hit; not ok to starve her.  So in that sense the law is un-Islamic.  Hey, maybe that’s what they meant!