Saturday, 22 November 2025

Confessions of an ex-pro-Palestinian

 

Some of the best insights in politics, current events and culture come from people who were previously True Believers (in whatever) and then changed their minds. 

Because they have to really examine their beliefs. It’s not easy. They cop grief from friends and family. Not many people do it, because it’s hard and alienates them from their longtime loved ones. 

Above we have Taryn Thomas talking about her experiences as a pro-Hamas activist and now pro-Israel, talking to The Free Press. 

Friday, 21 November 2025

Islamic Settler Colonial Imperialism

Elon and Jensen on the future of everything

Two of my heroes: Elon Musk and Jensen Huang, at a conference in Saudi Arabia. 

Here we have two genuine geniuses, two visionaries, giving us some ideas of where they see the world in ten or twenty years. I fear I won't be here to see if they're right or wrong, though I'm still hoping...

Now, I've never been a fan of Saudi Arabia. I think their government is horrid. The way they treat women, minorities, foreigners, non-Muslims, is horrid. They've been long run by the Wahhabi sect of Islam, one of the most extreme and horrid of a horrid religion. 

But... but... There's been some change at the top in recent years. They're no longer quite as horrid as they used to be. They've given women some rights. They kicked out the Muslim Brotherhood and have urged the west to do so as well. They're engaged with the west and want to become a part of growing with the future. 

This is far from a democracy. But it's a movement towards something better, less fundamentally Islamist, than it was. Surely we can support that. After all, how many other Islamic countries are moving in the direction of improvement? Answer: none. None, anyway, outside those who signed the Abraham Accords. 

We must not succumb, ever again, to ideas of "nation building", as did the W. Bush brigade and other "neocons" on the Right and the Left. We must give up the idea that we can instil "democracy" in middle eastern or south Asian states. 

But it would be smart of us, the west, to engage with those that are working to improvement. Surely that's something we ought to support. Rather than, like the Press, continue to slag Saudi because their secret police dismembered one of their members. Am I right?

And that's clearly what Elon and Jensen are doing. Following the lead of Donald Trump and his Abraham Accords.

Thanks for the vid to Aussie entrepreneur, Tesla Bull, YouTuber, the "man with three first names", Steven Mark Ryan.

Thursday, 20 November 2025

China: Past, Present and Future

Click above for the link to the radio pod

I knew Linda Jaivin, one of the writers featured in "China: Past, Present, Future", the radio podcast on Australia's ABC. We met in Beijing in 1976. She married one of my classmates, the China scholar Geremie Barmé. Though they've since separated, I believe, and he lives somewhere in the wilds of New Zealand. Though none of this is mentioned in the Wiki-entry. 

This is a really good talk, from people that really know China. I've been with Chinna and about China since 1976, still live in the Hong Kong part of China, but I  still learned stuff. Not that I agreed with every single thing, mind. But still, very good, and some wonderful insights. 

From the show notes: 

To deal with China as a major trading partner, and also a national security threat requires understanding the history that made China what it is today. 

That history is shaped by resistance and different waves of uprising. How have governments dealt with these movements? How do they influence politics today?

China: Past, Present, Future was recorded live at the 2025 Sydney Writers' Festival.

Listen to Big Ideas — Behrouz Boochani and Arnold Zable: The language of resistance

Speakers

Linda Jaivin
Australian author, cultural commentator, essayist and translator
Author of Bombard the Headquarters! China's Cultural Revolution

Louisa Lim
Award-winning journalist who reported from China for a decade for NPR and the BBC
Author of Indelible City: Dispossession and Defiance in Hong Kong

Edward Wong
American journalist and diplomatic correspondent for The New York Times
Author of At the Edge of Empire: A Family's Reckoning with China

Peter Hartcher (host)
Australian journalist and the Political and International Editor of The Sydney Morning Herald
Author of Red Zone: China's Challenge and Australia's Future.

Wednesday, 19 November 2025

China - Japan imbroglio: "The best outcome for China, Taiwan, the Globe, is the status quo" | Peter Forsythe

"The best outcome for China, Taiwan, the Globe, is the status quo"


Herewith a self-criticism.

I only just learned that there's a Sino-Japanese brouhaha. And I'm told it's serious. Just the latest one (I muse), but "it's serious!", I'm assured. 

Here's the thing. This would not have happened a few years ago. I would not have not known about this latest brouhaha. Because of newspapers. 

All my adult life I got hard copy newspapers, made out of actual paper. Here in Hong Kong it was the International Herald Tribune, the New York Times and the South China Morning Post, delivered to my front door every crack of dawn.

I'd come down for breakfast and luxuriate over an actual physical paper. It was a wonderful routine. 

What it meant was, one could know what was what in the world by the time of one's bus. At least the headlines. And in many cases, the story of the day in some detail. 

Then, over time, I let the hard copy subs lapse. As did most of the world. I did so a bit later than most -- the last one I finished just last year -- but finish the hard copy subscriptions I did. 

What I did was to take the digital version of all these. That means an App. But whereas there's only the paper newspaper in the morning, there's many Apps on one's phone. AI tells me that the average person has 60 to 80 Apps on their phone. I checked mine just now: I have 93! Yikes. 

So it's easy to forget. And since I -- we -- no longer watch the news on telly either, there's only what you get on the App if you go to the App. And sometimes I forget. I aim to look at my South China Morning Post App each day. After all, I do live in China, the Hong Kong part of it. But somehow haven't opened it for a week. I've been otherwise engaged with YouTube or doctors' visits. 

And so I've missed the story of the Japanese Prime Minister, the new one Sanae Takaichi, making a statement that made Beijing melt down in fury. I get told that by some OR's and that I ought to be incensed myself. And scared. 

Having looked into it now, I'm not incensed. And I'm not scared. 

Though for sure, this was avoidable and a mistake (I think) by the Japan PM, the newbie Sanae Takaichi. 

My basic thought about the situation is simple:

The best situation for China, Taiwan and the world is the status quo. We want things to just stay as they are. That's the best for all countries involved and for the world. 

Any war by China against Taiwan would be a regional and a global disaster. Even if China had a victory in landing on the island and taking over, it would be very much a Pyrrhic victory: with the costs way more than the benefits. 

With the status quo we have all the benefits of trade, investment, cross-border tourism and investment, with none of the costs. Taiwan is de facto independent, without the hassles of fighting for a de jure independence. The rest of the world trades with both, just fine. That's the way things are, and that's the best way things could ever be. Per Beatles: "Let it Be". 

I have long thought that the status quo was the best for China-Taiwan. Going back to my time in China in 1976, and my first visit to Taiwan in the same year. I learned of China's position on it. Pretty quickly I thought: this is something best left to be the proverbial can kicked down the proverbial road. Forever. 

Because it's very nice peace. As we have now. Or very awful war. Which would be disastrous. 

I've also said so on this blog over the years. Some examples below what I'm about to say.

Which, cleaned and tidied up, is this: 

"The best outcome for China, Taiwan, the Globe, is the status quo".
It has held for decades. It delivers prosperity to both sides of the Strait and prevents a catastrophic war that nobody could win cleanly. Beijing gains leverage by constant threats without paying the immense cost of actually firing a shot. 
Taipei preserves its democracy and its de facto independence. 
Washington keeps its policy of strategic ambiguity, which has deterred invasion while avoiding provocation. 
Everyone understands the rules. Everyone benefits from not breaking them.
That delicate balance is why no responsible leader should speak openly about Taiwan independence, and equally why no leader should spell out in public exactly what would trigger military support for Taipei. Strategic ambiguity works precisely because it is ambiguous. It forces Beijing to consider the worst-case scenario without giving it a clear casus belli.
Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi’s explicit linkage of a Taiwan contingency to Japan’s “survival-threatening situation” therefore broke a long-standing taboo. Her remarks were factually grounded in Japan’s 2015 security legislation, but stating them so plainly from the prime minister’s office was unnecessary and unwise. It handed Beijing a gift.
One could attribute it to inexperience – Takaichi has been in office less than a month. A more seasoned leader would have left the interpretation to staff officers and think-tank scholars. China, for its part, could simply have ignored the statement or filed a routine protest. Instead it chose maximum escalation: summoning the ambassador, military exercises, and a full-throated propaganda offensive.
That reaction was entirely predictable. On Weibo and WeChat (I get daily summaries) the response has been ferocious – wave after wave of virulent anti-Japanese hatred, calls for boycotts, historical grievances dredged up yet again, and wall-to-wall praise for the government’s “firm stand”. This is the standard playbook. Every external hint that Taiwan might not be unconditionally Chinese becomes an instant domestic rallying point. Which strengthens the Communist Party. the CCP does not need to invade Taiwan to profit from the Taiwan issue; it only needs the issue itself.
Meantime, the United States – the one power whose response actually matters – has remained remarkably calm. Neither President Trump nor Secretary of State Marco Rubio has amplified the controversy. Washington understands the game and has chosen not to play.
My guess: Beijing will not launch a war over a single Japanese prime ministerial statement. It will not invade Taiwan because of it. Nor should it. The noise will die down in a week or two, the patrols will return to their normal rhythm and the status quo – that quietly successful arrangement – will still be the least bad option for everyone. Cross fingers.

The lesson is simple: keep quiet, keep cool, and let ambiguity do its essential work. 

Here endeth the lesson.

===========================

Some references I've made to China-Taiwan status quo in the posts on this blog:

What did the Occupy Central leader think it would achieve by meeting Shih Ming-teh [the former chairman of the pro-independence Democratic Progressive Party in Taiwan]? It's simply not worth getting Beijing riled and suspicious. 
It strikes me as dangerous and boneheaded for the demonstrators to storm Legco (HK's parliament) vandalise the interior and especially to fly British flags. Crazy, silly, juvenile, counterproductive and dangerous. The same for calls for Taiwan "independence". 
If there is war over Taiwan it will only be because Beijing starts it. Taiwan just needs to stand pat, to keep saying “the status quo is best”. Because it is. And not call for “Independence”. Don’t do that. Don’t tweak the dragon’s tail.
Anyhow: let's hope Warburg and I are right. The status quo is the most attractive, for sure. We hope that China, Beijing, also sees that it is.

Autumn at our pool

Clear Fall Days. Dome of Discovery College rooftop swimming pool behind.

Tuesday, 18 November 2025

Sunrise over Central, Hongkong

From Siena Park, Discovery Bay, this morning
Do a 180 degree turn from top photo and you get this... 
...our dear Labradoodle, the tall, the elegant, the popular, the slightly crazy, Byron, lolling toungue, exhausted from chasing the ball.... 

Enjoying his walk along the Siena Promenade. Enjoying the sunrise.

Photos, courtesy Arlene. 

Sunday, 16 November 2025

"Energy is Life". The case for nuclear energy | Zion Lights

Click above for the article

I've followed Zion Lights for many years. She was a major mover in very leftie Green organisations, like Greenpeace and Extinction Rebellion. Until, she says, she realised all they did was criticise, without offering anything positive to be done. 

That got her onto the Nuclear issue. She's now a powerful advocate. That's something to be done. 

From her Substack article: 

After many years of exploring energy and climate change, from dropping banners and giving viral interviews, to recreating memes, to publicly pivoting from one side to the other and everything in between, I am thrilled to announce that my new book, Energy is Life, is now available for pre-order. This project is the culmination of my curiosity, research, and passion for storytelling, and I’m excited to finally share it with you.

I’ve spent the past decade writing about science, climate, energy, and technology. Along the way, I’ve noticed something curious: the stories we tell about the future are often either terrifying or oversimplified. ‘Renewable’ energy is framed as a magic bullet; nuclear is treated like a four-letter word; AI is either a saviour or an existential threat. And the public, unsurprisingly, struggles to separate hype from reality.

So I decided to write a book that cuts through the noise. It’s not just about data, or policies, or even the latest breakthroughs in energy or AI. It’s about why we sometimes ignore evidence, how curiosity and ingenuity actually change the world, and what happens when science meets society’s messiness. It’s about us - humankind - and the choices we make that shape the future. More importantly, it’s also about what we might achieve if we get things right.

In the book, I explore questions like:

  • Why did many environmentalists ‘ go nuclear’ against clean energy, even as they worried about climate change?

  • How could nuclear energy realistically help decarbonise our energy system?

  • Why do people ignore evidence, and how can we communicate better without talking down to them?

  • How and why did so many people change their stance on nuclear energy?

  • What could humanity achieve in a world of abundant, reliable energy?

Saturday, 15 November 2025

BBC: “…a deep desire to always think the worst of Israel” | Natasha Hausdorff

 

The BBC’s deliberate and wilful hatred of Israel, its support for every Hamas lie and swallowing of all Hamas propaganda has shaped world opinion against Israel. Against Israel's legitimate war against the worst, the most barbaric terror organisation on the planet: its neighbour, Hamas. 

Natasha Hausdorff describes her own experience as a commentator in the BBC. It’s damning. 

Right at the beginning of this Gaza war there was the story of the bombing of the Al-Shifa hospital. 

In reality it was the result of a Palestinian Islamic Jihad rocket falling short and accidentally landing near the hospital. But it was presented as a perfidious and  deliberate air attack on the innocent hospital by Israel's IDF. The BBC didn’t want to know the true story, even though it was known early on, as Natasha describes. The BBC published the false narrative and promoted the false narrative. A kind of "publish and be damned"; in this case "publish and damn Israel". 

I remember the incident. I remember how it coloured people’s perceptions at the time. How could it not? If you believed those horrid Joooz deliberately bombed a hospital!? With children in it?? Of course you're going to think they're war criminals. 

It's the BBC, not Israel, who's criminal. It's the BBC who's against the Good. It's the BBC who's pro the Bad. It's the BBC who's anti-western. 

Why? 

I can only assume it's the neo-Marxism that they're steeped in. I mean you just have to listen to some of them talk. Reminds me of my early days in Mao's China; and the lectures from my teachers on the wonder of the Cultural Revolution. 

The BBC neo-marxist world views lead them to support anyone who they judge to be "oppressed" by anyone they judge as horrid "oppressors", no matter the rights and wrongs of the issue at hand. 

The BBC see Palestinians as being oppressed and Israel as the oppressor. No matter the rights and wrongs of that issue. No matter the rights and wrongs of the narrative the Palestinians spin. No matter the rights and wrongs of the actual true history of this Holy Land. No matter the rights and wrongs of the establishment of Israel. No matter the number of times the Palestinians have been offered land for peace, and rejected every offer. No matter the rights and wrongs of that.
======================
As I write this, I hear the news of a plane load of Palestinian "refugees" that have landed in Tambo airport in South Africa. The SA government is not allowing them in. Why? Pretoria won't say. 

But we know. We can make a pretty good guess. 

South Africa is not letting them in for the same reason that Lebanon won't take them in. That Jordan won't take them in. That Syria won't take them in. That Egypt won't take them in. 

Because in each of those places, when they've let in Palestinian refugees, the Palestinians have created murderous havoc. Civil war in Lebanon -- that continues to this day. Massacres in Syria. The Black September terror attacks in the Jordanian kingdom. Terror attacks in Cairo. 

The only places accepting Palestinian refugees are western: We silly billies in Australia and some in Europe. More fools us. More virtue-signalling fools us. 

Friday, 14 November 2025

"Why China won't invade Taiwan" | Paul Warburg

 

I don't know Paul Warburg -- I came across him just today -- but he makes good sense, above. It's kinda long, but worth it for those interested in the geo-politics of our region here in East Asia. 

I've long thought the best thing for China-Taiwan relations is simple: the status quo.

There's no real good outcome for China for an attack on the island of Taiwan, which would be fraught at best. 

Meantime: Beijing threatens. And gets a lot of attention for that. It gets leverage. The best outcome for China is precisely the current one: keep pressure on the world, keep it wrong footed, use the leverage of threats to "regain" the "renegade province" in any international negotiations. 

But don't actually do anything. 

China would have a tough time if it did attack Taiwan. It has a limited amphibious landing fleet, that can only slowly be replenished. It has no decent Blue Water fleet. Its two aircraft carriers are ancient Russian rust buckets.  

Taiwan is protected by its mountainous terrain and limited beaches to land on. It's defensible. Taiwan now has huge inventories of anti-ship and anti-aircraft missiles and the latest military drone technology from Ukraine. All the pressure would be on the attackers. 

Meantime Taiwanese are 70-80% in favour if staying just as it is. No interest there in becoming part of the motherland. Our Hong Kong experience has made it clear to Taiwanese just what it means to have "One Country, Two Systems", an early strategy of China, to make it seem attractive to its "renegade" to come back into the embrace of the Motherland. Since the 2020 Hong Kong riots and the resulting National Security legislation, that's no longer a reasonable hope.

Another thought: China has had no experience of war or battles since it fought Vietnam in 1979.  Which didn't go well. It now has 45 years of Zero experience in war, apart from a few trifling border skirmishes with India. The United States, meantime, for better or worse, has been in almost constant war. Its Navy is well practiced and hugely outguns and out-technologies the Chinese. Some war game scenarios have China winning; but, really, I can't see them winning against the battle-hardened, technologically superior US Fleet, assuming it came in support of its ally Taiwan. Don't believe me? Check out some of the amazing vids of on-board training exercises on US carriers. 

I've also seen reports that Chinese naval commanders are not up to chop. They're inexperienced soyboys.... (So goes the scuttlebut). FNGs in military slang.

Warburg also suggests that a number of countries in the region -- Vietnam, Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia, Japan -- would come to the support of Taiwan, in case of any Chinese aggression. 

As for the Naval Blockade scenario. The trouble with that from China's point of view is that it's easily countered. A blockade of Taiwan would lead to counter blockades of China, blockades of the Straits of Malacca, of the ports of Burma, Bangladesh and Pakistan. It would see a catastrophic drop in its trade and in imports of energy. 

And all for what? For pride? For getting hold of Taiwan's chip industry? (not likely to survive a war). For... what.... I don't see it. A game not worth the candle. 

Anyhow: let's hope Warburg and I are right. The status quo is the most attractive, for sure. We hope that China, Beijing, also sees that it is. 

Decoding Dogs...

 


Thursday, 13 November 2025

The real population bomb: DEpopulation

We were discussing population decline. 

Example: 

South Korea’s population is around 51 million. Its current birth rate is 0.8 per fertile woman. 

That means in 2 generations, 40 years, in the lifetime of our kids, its population will decline to under 12 million. In 3 generations, 60 years, it will fall to just 4 million. 

IOW: In 60 years, South Korea will have less than one person for every ten people it has today. 

Most of that population will be old. 

The same sorts of declines are already happening in all the developed world, all of Europe, most of Asia and even much of the developing world. 

Food for thought.

Wednesday, 12 November 2025

Venezuelan drug boats, speeding across the Gulf, are the new terrorism. For Sure.


It's simple:

If you're not a narco-terrorist, don't be driving a speedboat with 4 x 600 hp "super-high-quad" outboards; don't be carrying cocaine-shaped plastic bags stuffed to the scuppers; don't be travelling with four dudes, not a single one interested in fishing; don't be flying across the open waters of the Gulf of America at 60 knots aiming for the wild coasts of Texas. 

Don't be doing that. And you'll be fine.

Do that, and prepare to meet thy maker, terrorist!

I'm fine with these simple rules. 

Tuesday, 11 November 2025

Israel is the best manager of lands in the middle east

 What Joshua Carr says in the above video is true. Israel is far and away the best country in the region, in terms of its control of land, of its rights and laws, of its historical ownwership and stewardship of the land on which it sits today. 

Somewhere else, I think it was Dinesh D'Souza, there's the concept of what it means to be a genuine, bona fide, proper country. Three things according to Dinesh, or any one of these three things:

1. History. You're the indigenous people on the land.
2. Law: you get an authority to name you a State.
3. Control: you control an area of land because you fought for it. 

Israel has all three of these: 

1. It's been in the land of Judea and Samaria since 3,000 BCE. 
2. The United Nations accepted it as a nation in 1947.
3. Israel has fought repeated wars for its existence. It has gained land. In some cases given it back to the original owners (without it's bringing them any peace), in other cases (the "west bank") these areas remaining "disputed territories". 

In sum: no other lands, no other countries, have such a strong claim to nationhood in the land the currently occupy, as does Israel. Yet it's the most demonised. 

More importantly: Israel is a genuine democracy. Where all faiths and ethnicities are equal and have equal rights. Where there are more practicing Christians living free and safe lives, than in any single other of the surrounding 22 Arab Muslim states. Where 22% of the population is Arab Muslim. Where Muslims are on the Supreme Court. Where Muslims -- as all other religions -- can vote in Israeli elections.

Don’t believe it? Do as Joshua Carr did. And as we did. Visit Israel. Then visit Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt, Iran, Pakistan. Or anywhere surrounding Israel. And conclude a fair account of which is best tended. Of which best looks after its citizens. Of which best runs its economy. Of which has the best and most advanced technology. Of which is building and which is not.

I'm glad Joshua Carr gets it. Many people don't. Or willfully decide not to get it.

Long Live Israel! 

"Blood in the Bars: Shanghai's Midnight Raids and Modern Collective Punishment"

This is a placeholder. 

To remind me to write a piece around the story a mate from Beijing, currently in Hong Kong, told me the other night when he visited us here in Hong Kong. 

He told us that the atmosphere in China these days is the worst and most negative he's felt in the nearly half century he's been in China. 

As an example: he said that he'd been in Bar in Shanghai, which was raided by the local cops. Who demanded a blood test from everyone in the place. If you refused, you were assumed guilty. If foreign you were deported in 48 hours. 

If you assented to the Blood Test, and you tested positive to any drug at all, you were deported within 48 hours. If Chinese, you were arrested. 

Families of those charged with the crime of having drugs in their blood, were deported or arrested along with the culprit. A form of "Collective punishment", I murmured. 

Someone said she thought Beijing's current harshness of its crackdown on drugs might hearken back to the Opium Wars. The Century of Humiliation. They are paranoid about the country again becoming a nation of addicts. 

"Oh, god, still blaming the colonists, after two hundred years!" I screamed. But left it at that... 

The convo moved on. I thought of a lot more things after. Which will be the subject of a later post. 

The theme will be: 

China has played the Victimhood Card ever since the Opium Wars. It has used and continues to use that victimhood card to guilt-trip the west into giving them favourable treatment, as we did for its accession to the World Trade Organisation. 

To make that case, I have to make the case that the Opium wars, that opium itself, were not as bad, as horrid, as pernicious, as they Chinese have made them out to be. 

That turn out to be an easy case to make. The data support it. 

I'll make it later though. 

Right now, I have to handle a Brie Cheese that I'm in the process of making and maturing. Gotta go... TTFN.