Saturday, 15 August 2009

"Abusing Women and Islam"

Mona Eltahawy claims that there is no sanction in Islam for the various “crimes” (her quote marks) such as women wearing trousers, having sex outside marriage and drinking alcohol (“Abusing Women and Islam”, IHT August 15-16).  She is wrong on all counts.
The standard manual of Islamic jurisprudence, the ‘Umdat al Salik  is the accepted authority of all Sunni schools of Islamic, Sharia law (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi’i and Hanbali).  It is certified, inter alia, by Cairo’s Al-Azhar University, co-sponsor of Obama’s recent speech to Muslims and the chief centre of Islamic learning in the Sunni world.
Of women wearing trousers, it says: “The Prophet cursed men who wear women’s clothing and women who wear men’s.” (p28.1.3).
Of sex outside marriage: “If the offender is someone with the capacity to remain chaste, then he or she is stoned to death”. (o12.2).  If the offender does not have the capacity to remain chaste, the penalty is reduced to 100 lashes.  So that's ok then...
Of drinking alcohol:  “the penalty for drinking is to be scourged forty stripes…. It may be administered with a whip…”. (o16.3)
To claim that there is no punishment in the Koran or the Hadith for drinking alcohol, without mentioning punishments in the Sharia, is rather like referring to the Bible and not Common Law and claiming, for example, that there’s no mention of insider trading in the Bible.  The Sunni men carrying out the punishments Ms Eltahawy rightly deplores are simply applying crystal-clear Islamic law.  To be outraged is right.  To direct the outrage at other than Islamic law itself, and especially at the “international community”, is futile. 
Ms Eltahawy would do well to read works by another Egyptian woman Nonie Darwish, for they are rather more insightful on these issues than the usual pabulum about the “justice and compassion “in the “religion of peace”.

Thursday, 13 August 2009

Swashbucklers of the day


I've been reading and listening and watching  -- Robert Altman's 2006 movie A Prairie Home Companion, which Keillor wrote and appeared in -- the wonderful, whimsical curmudgeon Garrison Keillor since I first heard, many years ago, his Prairie Home Companion on BBC International Radio (675 AM here in Hong Kong).  The Beebs international got taken over by a bunch of anti-fun nutters a few years ago and did away with all the comedy and loopy quiz shows (Just a Minute!) and turned it into a humourless top-of-the-hour bottom-of-the-hour non-stop news cycle; but that's another story.  
Today, GK dilates on the fun of blogging (btw, he looks pretty good for 67, doesn't he?):
What the new media age also means is that there won’t be newspapers to send reporters to cover the next war, but there will be 6 million teenage girls blogging about their plans for the weekend. There will be no TV networks to put on dramas in which actors in costume strut and orate and gesticulate, but you can see home video of dogs and anybody’s high school graduation anywhere in America. The U.S. will be a nation of unpaid freelance journalists and memoirists. This is not necessarily a bad thing.

It comes too late for Richard Nixon or Bill Clinton. In the new media age, there would not be a Watergate or a Monica Lewinsky. The president could conspire to break the law or canoodle with anybody within arm’s reach and likely there would be nobody in the forest to hear that particular tree fall. And that would be just fine. All we got from those enormous Old Media events, frankly, was entertainment. They were no more enlightening than a Harold Robbins novel.

I’m an old media guy and I love newspapers, but they were brought down by a long period of gluttonous profits when they were run as monopolies by large, phlegmatic, semi-literate men who endowed schools of journalism that labored mightily to stamp out any style or originality and to create a cadre of reliable transcribers. That was their role, crushing writers and rolling them into cookie dough. Nobody who compares newspaper writing to the swashbuckling world of blogging can have any doubt where the future lies. Bloggers are writers who’ve been liberated from editors, and some of them take you back to the thrilling days of frontier journalism, before the colleges squashed the profession.

The Internet is a powerful tide that is washing away some enormous castles and releasing a lovely sense of independence and playfulness in Americans. Millions of people have discovered the joys of seeing yourself in print — your own words! the unique essence of yourself, your stories, your jokes, your own peculiar take on the world — out there where anybody can see it! Wowser.

 

Wednesday, 12 August 2009

I was at Woodstock 40 years ago... weren't you??


Woodstock’s weekend of Music and Art was 40 years ago this Saturday, August 15.

Remember the times?  We were all there, we baby boomers.   Oh yes, we were! In spirit if not in body.  I was in Canberra, saw the movie as soon as it came out in January 1970, went straight to the Woodstock Pizza Parlour in Garema place as soon as it opened – how cool is that?  That's Sally and me, at it....(not.  It's us at the Nurses' Ball, September 1970, fully baring the spirit of times)

There are plenty of tributes to the Festival.  There’s a great Director’s Cut of the movie with a whole new DVD of just the music, worth the purchase price alone.  I bought it the other day and have reveled in it. 

 In the press, amongst many tributes, there’s “A moment of muddy grace” in the NY Times.  Make sure you have a look at the readers’ photos. 

Jon Pareles says:

Seemingly within minutes after it ended Woodstock was the stuff of legend: a spirit, a nation, an ideal, amorphous but vivid, with an Oscar-winning documentary film, the 1970 “Woodstock,” to prove it wasn’t all a hallucination.

 

And concludes:

Woodstock was different. It was, particularly for a sheltered teenager, an adventure: sloppy, chaotic, bewildering, drenched, uncertain, sometimes excruciating, sometimes ecstatic. Although I was drug free, I had the feeling that the crowd was more than just an audience at a show, that something major was at stake, that Woodstock would prove something to the world. What it proved — that for at least one weekend, hippies meant what they said about peace and love — was fleeting and all too innocent; it couldn’t stand up to everyday human nature or to the pragmatic workings of the market. But 40 years later the sensation lingers.

And for those of us on the on the other side of the globe, and perhaps not quite so drug fee, it was equally a time of adventure, sloppy, chaotic, brilliant, fun, full of promise, wonderful music, ecstatic.   Yes, I was there....   there I am....


Letters to the editor

A reader asks: "what's with all the 'letters to editors?'  Don't you get any published?".  Well, yes, over the years, rate of publication to the local press, South China Morning Post is almost 100%.   As long as I write about local issues.  If the topic is Islam, then there's no way they print, no matter how muted or fact-based the comment.  Today the SCMP prints one of mine, following a recent series of letters questioning the place of English in Hong Kong (links in the letter sent here):

Victor Ho, a visitor to Hong Kong from the United States, says "In the US highly qualified Asian executives are never promoted beyond middle management" ("Differing views on the importance of English in Hong Kong", August 8).

That is incorrect. In the list of Fortune 500 companies I counted 16 Asian CEOs, 3.2 per cent of the total. The Asian population of the US is about 4.4 per cent, so there is a slight under-representation, but hardly the glass ceiling of which Mr Ho complains. And it is simply not true that Asians are "never promoted".

Ho says the rationale for the glass ceiling is because Asians are soft spoken.

If a non-Asian made that claim it would rightly be judged an ignorant stereotype. It is equally ignorant coming from a US-based Asian. Mr Ho has clearly never been to a Hong Kong restaurant at festival time.

His muddled thinking somehow leads him to the conclusion that English is not important [in Hong Kong].

True, it may not be the only, or even the major, reason for Hong Kong's success. But is one of our unique selling propositions. It is one that our motherland is eagerly embracing. Why would we want to ditch it?

Avaaz petition -- Aung San Suu Kyi

A friend just sent me this below. (I’m really not sure these sorts of things can do much good, but surely no harm, and I’ve signed it…) Info on Avaaz organisation is at the link.
Hi − After thirteen years of detention, Burmese pro democracy hero and Nobel Peace laureate Aung San Suu Kyi has just been condemned to another year and a half on trumped up charges.
I just signed an urgent petition urging the United Nations Security Council to take action to end the Burmese tyranny and hold the regime to account not just for this cruelty, but for all the vicious crimes that they have committed against monks, children and thousands of ethnic minorities. I thought that you would want to join me by calling for a UN Commission of Inquiry and together we can bring justice to Burma!

Click this link to sign the petition and see links below for more information:

The politics behind the guilty verdict
Read the Harvard report
The United Nations Official's appeal to the Security Council
For the UK MPs call for Commission of Inquiry 

Tuesday, 11 August 2009

Why no Aussie nuclear option?

A climate change bill is to be discussed (disputed?) next week in Australia’s parliament. 

As Peter Hartcher reports, Rudd’s Climate Change Bill contains two main provisions: 

One is to require that all power companies get at least 20 per cent of their energy from renewable sources - solar, wind or tide - by 2020. The Opposition supports Rudd in this aim.

The other is the controversial one - an emissions trading scheme. This is simply a way of rationing carbon output. It would it raise the price of carbon-based energy, encouraging Australia to use less oil and coal and more renewable energy. The great weaning will have begun. 

What I don’t get is: why is there no discussion in Australia of the nuclear option? We have huge reserves of uranium.  Nuclear energy is clean of carbon, safe and proven.   There are safe ways to dispose of the waste – deep geological storage.  We’re quite happy to sell the stuff, but not to use it ourselves.   Isn’t that just hypocrisy?  

Monday, 10 August 2009

Blanch that organic broccoli

A reader writes, in response to my knocking organic food: 

Only glanced down the page and came upon the mention of "organic food" in a negative light  --- and blanched, of course. Forget the nutritional content --- I understand from what "they" say that its cultivation is much better for the environment, even from a global warming perspective. Ergo (as this is a learned discussion), you ought to support it!
Couple of points I'd make:
1. I'm not sure that organic food is better for the environment.  See article here, from the left-of-centre Independent, "Organic food no better for the environment".
2. It's hard on the wallet: three times the price for "organic" Weetabix than "Original" Weetabix, for goodness sake!  Is that worth it?  Scientists say that the trace amounts of added chemicals are in such amounts that you'd have to eat a truckload in a day for there to be any impact.
3. Organic farming has lower yields than non-organic.  It takes something like three times the amount of land to grow our staples organically than not.  We could not feed the broad masses of poor people if we went fully organic.  

Sunday, 9 August 2009

Romantics and Realists


Drinks the other night found the Romantic in discussion with the Realist.  The Youth and the Elder.  The former feels that all people want the same thing: security and well-being for their families; so we should all be able to live together in peace, abrogate war, the lion supine with the lamb.  The Realist grants that we are all born equal, but not all acculturated equally: some are acculturated to hate us, and want to kill us, just because we don't believe what they do.  And they want to kill the Romantic as well.  As I'm the one writing the blog, I could have the last word here.  But let me give that to the inimitable Patrick Condell in his video, "Apologists for Evil".

Green shoots in Palestine. Really?

“The bad news” says Thomas Friedman, (Green Shoots in Palestine, International Herald Tribune, Aug 4), “things have gotten worse” since the first Arab Human Development Report of 2002.  His summary of the 2009 Report discusses the deterioration of "deficits" in three areas:  (i) Freedom  (ii) Women’s empowerment and (iii) Knowledge-creation.  Not once does Friedman mention Islam, and the report itself mentions it only in passing.   Clearly too hot a potato.  
Perhaps Islam is not the only reason for these worsening problems, but it is surely one of the most important.  It is so, because all the 25 members of the Arab world are predominantly Islamic, with Islam playing a far more important part in the political and cultural life than, say, Christianity does in Europe.  For Islam is a total system, a "whole way of life", and in many of the Arab countries the Constitution is based on Islamic Sharia law.  To talk about the problems in the Arab world without mentioning Islam is like analysing why the Twin Towers collapsed without mentioning the planes....
Consider:
Freedom: Islam places no emphasis on personal freedom.  The very word means “Submission” to the will of God, as channeled through imams, ayatollahs and caliphs.  The sign below sums this up pretty succinctly:  the official Islamic view of freedom. 
Women’s empowerment: Islam is rightly notorious for its treatment of women as second-class citizens, routinely denied their basic human rights.
Knowledge-creation:  Sharia law prohibits “innovation” and the whole corpus of Islamic doctrine is against curiosity and scientific advancement (see  The Reliance of the Traveller, the manual of Islamic jurisprudence). 

As long as the Islamic politico-religious edifice exerts its baleful influence, by the time of the next Arab Development report, Friedman will surely have to conclude, yet again:  “Things have gotten worse”. 
This is Islam's position on western Freedom.  In Islam, one is only "free" to submit

English in Hong Kong

US visitor to Hong Kong Victor Ho says “In the US highly qualified Asian executives are never promoted beyond middle management.“ (Differing views on the importance of English in Hong Kong, Aug 8).
That is incorrect.  In the list of Fortune 500 companies I counted 16 Asian CEOs, 3.2% of the total.  The Asian population of the US is about 4.4%,  so there is a slight underrepresentation, but hardly the “glass ceiling” of which Ho complains.  And it is simply not true that Asians are “never promoted”.  
Ho says the “rationale” for the “glass ceiling” is “because we [Asians] are quiet and soft [sic] spoken”.  If a non-Asian made that claim it would rightly be judged an ignorant and racist stereotype.  It is equally ignorant coming from a US-based Asian; Ho has clearly never been to a Hong Kong restaurant at festival time.
Ho’s muddled thinking somehow leads him to the conclusion that English is not important.  True, it may not be the only, or even the major, reason for Hong Kong’s success.  But is one of our Unique Selling Propositions.  It is one that our Motherland is eagerly embracing.  Why would we want to ditch it?

Wednesday, 5 August 2009

The Aussie Jihadis

Letter sent to The Age today. There's little chance of its being run, but I hope some sub-editors might read it and absorb something.... The Australian public is, I think, more robust on the Jihadi terror threat than the media or politicians.

UPDATE: The Age did run the letter, slightly edited, on its 12 August Letters page. A bit surprising to me, given its left-of-centre leanings. Still, I'll take it.

My letter as sent:

RE:  Melbourne terror accused…. The Age, 5 August 2009

Two of your Op-ed contributors, Daniel Flitton, “New twist in the old, familiar al-Qaeda story”, and Berhan Ahmed, “Strong African communities will defeat terror recruiters”, both of August 5, 2009, offer variations of the “tiny minority of extremist” arguments, to urge caution and treatment of the events “with care”.
But are the would-be Jihadis a "tiny section of the community" (Flitton), or a "few marginalized people" (Ahmed)?
In a poll conducted in 2007 and broadcast on Britain's Channel 4 TV, nearly 25% of British Muslims said the July 7, 2005, terror bombings in London were justified. Another 30% said they would prefer to live under strict Islamic Sharia law rather than England's democratic system.
One in four justifying terror may not be a majority, but it certainly isn't a "tiny section" either.  Is there any reason -- other than wishful thinking -- to think that the figures in Australia would be significantly different?
Perhaps a “tiny minority” is a matter of personal opinion.  Reuters, for example, reported on October 15, 2006, that “just” 10 percent of Indonesian Muslims said they backed jihad and supported bomb attacks on the island of Bali aimed at foreign tourists.  But Indonesia is home to more than 200 million Muslims, which means there are some 20 million Muslims in Indonesia alone who are willing to say out loud that they support the use of violence and terror against innocent human beings.
Australia needs to wake up to the threat within our society from Jihadis driven by well-documented and clear Islamic doctrine, which calls for the killing of non-Muslims.  No amount of trying to deal with “marginalisation” or “alienation”, or adjusting our foreign policy, is going to appease such people.  A robust facing up to the Jihadi’s motivation is the first step in trying to deal with the threat.

Dealing with the opium poppy: it's time for real change

Sent to the South China Morning Post today.  I doubt they'll run it, as they usually like the letters to be about local issues, like the plastic bag levy (a long-runner), or, the most recent one exercising the minds of readers: whether or not the new economy class seats on Cathay are comfortable....

Regarding “Bashing the Poor”, by Rukmini Callimachi SCMP, 4 August 09
 Dear Sir,
There was an infamous phrase of the Vietnam war, supposedly uttered in 1968 by a US army officer: “we had to destroy the village in order to save it.”  Forty years later we hear the same twisted logic, this time in Afghanistan:
‘“These poor farmers are going to get stepped on and get hurt in this effort," says... Doug Wankel, who organised [the US’]… counter-narcotics effort in the area in 2003. "But it's a pain that has to be endured for the good of the masses.”’  (Bashing the Poor, 4 Aug). 
Callimachi’s article is a generally sympathetic piece, which highlights the devastation to the livelihood of poor Afghan farmers caused by the US-led efforts to destroy the opium poppy crop, for the supposed “good of the masses.” 
I was disappointed that Callimachi made no mention of an alternative solution: legalise and control the crop, estimated to be worth some $US 4 billion per year.  The war on terror is costing the US alone some $US 11 billion per month, a total of $223 billion in Afghanistan alone to 2009 (source: Congressional Research Service, May 09).  Less than two-weeks’ worth of US expenditure would buy the annual Afghan crop.  The idea is that the crop purchase would be controlled by the UN, converted into medicinal morphine – with the construction and running of processing facilities providing jobs – and sent to poor areas of Africa which need analgesic drugs.  How much better all round this would be.  At a stroke it provides income to farmers, provides jobs to build and run processing facilities and provides medicine for the poor in Africa, while it removes the main source of illicit cash from the Taliban.
Why does Obama not live up to his slogan of “Change” and make a real change, instead of more of the same: a surge of troops and destruction of farmers’ livelihoods. Why does he not make real Change for the good of the masses of the world?

Friday, 31 July 2009

Organic food "unlikely to be of any public health relevance."

Not wanting to seem obsessed by this organic food business, but the report I mentioned yesterday appeared in today's South China Morning Post.  "The independent study, funded by the United Kingdom Food Standards Agency... concluded that organic food was "unlikely to be of any public health relevance".

The response of the director of the HK Organic Resource Centre?  "Simply comparing the nutritional breakdown of organic and inorganic food without looking into their growth background is unreliable."   What??  Parse that one (or "deconstruct" it, as the post-modernists would say).  Surely "comparing the nutritional breakdown" is exactly what we should be doing.

Anyway, in our household the order has gone out: don't buy organic, unless you have to.  There you go, that's my little revolt.

Was it X-files where they said: "I want to believe"?  Blow the evidence.

Thursday, 30 July 2009

Hurrah for pesticides and artificial fertilisers!

I've long had a campaign in this family -- only sporadically successful -- to drink tap water and pooh-pooh organic produce.  I reckon it's all a big con.  I recall a scientist on the BBC saying that there was indeed measurable pesticide in a cauliflower he'd tested, but that you'd have to eat a truckload of it in a day for it to make any difference.  Meantime Organic Weetabix are three times as expensive as the "Original".   Three times!  I actually got some "Organic" and "Original" Weetabix tested here in Hong Kong and though there were detectable chemicals in the Original, they were in vanishingly small amounts and, like the cauliflower, you'd have to eat truckloads of it, in a day, for it to -- perhaps -- have any effect.

I just heard a report on BBC Radio (675 AM in Hong Kong), which said that a recent study of 50 years' worth of research revealed no measurable health benefits from eating "organic" food.

Even more damning: if the world shifted to organic production, we could only produce about a quarter of what we do now.  Mass famine would be the logical outcome of a leftie-greenie agenda on this organic foods wankery.

I can't find the link to the article mentioned by the BBC.  Email me if you know: peter-at-forsythe-dot-hk (my address in this format so that crawlbots don't pick up my email address for spamming)

Why won't America speak to Israel?

I wrote about Israel and West Jerusalem yesterday, here.   Today's International Herald Tribune prints two letters on the same topic:
Regarding Celestine Bohlen’s “Telling Israel no: Obama’s bold move” (Letter from Europe, July 29): The Palestinians are not in any way, shape or form ready to negotiate; they are split in a million pieces. The Palestinian Authority is corrupt and ineffectual; Hamas is terrorizing Gaza’s population; Gaza is hemmed in on all sides by Egypt and Israel; Iran is a mess.
What good does it do to pressure Israel on settlements when the other partner in the conflict is in never-never land?
This has been the story all along. The Palestinians refuse to negotiate seriously; the Israelis take more land. In the end, there won’t be any land to negotiate over.
Andrea Moriah, Jerusalem
James Carroll (“A shared Jerusalem,” Views, July 28) writes that “President Obama has replaced the Bush policy of hands-off with a gloves-off readiness to push all parties hard.”
Can Mr. Carroll point to anything at all that Mr. Obama has done that could be interpreted as pushing the Palestianians?
Tuvia Fogel, Milan

Hillary in, Sarah out

Funny piece by Mareen Dowd, she who coined the term the "slutty stewardess look" for Sarah Palin.  
 
Concludes Mareen:

Sarah seems happily oblivious that she benefited from Hollywood casting techniques. Just as movie directors have beautiful young actresses playing nuclear physicists and Harvard professors, knowing the fusion of sex appeal and a heavyweight profession will excite, the novelty of a beautiful former beauty queen and TV reporter cast in a powerful role that has featured dour, gray old men like Dick Cheney was thrilling. At first.

As McCain pal and Republican strategist Mike Murphy so sagely observed recently: “If Palin looked like Golda Meir, would we even be talking about her today?”

Sarah should follow her own advice to Hillary and work harder to be capable. Until then, she’s all cage, no bird.

A bit of a babe herself, young Maureen.  But I guess we'd still take her as seriously if she did look like Gold Meir; she writes in black and white, after all.

59 is the new 30. Yeah!

Lovely article by Thomas L. Friedman in today's International Herald Tribune, here. Contemplating Tom Watson's amazing run in the British Open:
...a 59-year-old man who had played his opening two rounds in this tournament with a 16-year-old Italian amateur — was able to best the greatest golfers in the world at least a decade after anyone would have dreamt it possible.
...
This wonderful but cruel game never stops testing or teaching you. “The only comment I can make,” Watson told me after, “is one that the immortal Bobby Jones related: ‘One learns from defeat, not from victory.’ I may never have the chance again to beat the kids, but I took one thing from the last hole: hitting both the tee shot and the approach shots exactly the way I meant to wasn’t good enough. ... I had to finish.”

So I went out with Kev, to the DB Golf Course and shot a 14 over.  That's 14 balls over.... over the fence, in the rough and lost.  Cruel, yes....  What I learn from defeat: buy cheap balls....

Wednesday, 29 July 2009

Why won't America speak to Israel?

Thoughtful article in today's International Herald Tribune, by Aluf Benn, editor-at-large of the Israeli liberal paper Haaretz.  Points made include:

Mr. Obama’s quest for diplomacy has appeared to Israelis as dangerous American naïveté. The president offered a hand to the Iranians, and got nothing, merely giving them more time to advance their nuclear program. 
....

Mr. Obama seems to have confused American Jews with Israelis. We are close emotionally and politically, but we are different. We speak Hebrew and not English, we live in the Middle East and have separate historical narratives. Mr. Obama’s stop at Buchenwald and his strong rejection of Holocaust denial, immediately after his Cairo speech, appealed to American Jews but fell flat in Israel. Here we are taught that Zionist determination and struggle — not guilt over the Holocaust — brought Jews a homeland. Mr. Obama’s speech, which linked Israel’s existence to the Jewish tragedy, infuriated many Israelis who sensed its closeness to the narrative of enemies like Mahmoud Ahmedinejad.
....
Mr. Obama has made a mistake in focusing on a settlement freeze. For starters, mainstream Israelis rarely have anything to do with the settlements; many have no idea where they are, even when they’re a half-hour’s drive from Tel Aviv....
Which leads to the settlement issue, including that of East Jerusalem.  Celestine Bohen's article in today's IHT makes the incorrect statement that the US has not recognised Israel's claim to East Jerusalem.  Her article here.  My letter to the IHT refuting her point, here.

Next time in Shanghai, check this place out..


James Cornell at his New Zealand specialty shop.

From the article in today's South China Morning Post (29th July):
The crumbling stone walls that surround the Tian Zi Fang neighbourhood in Shanghai belie a colourful and fascinating corner of the city, with a cosmopolitan mixture of shops, restaurants and galleries.


Its cluster of tiny Shikumen cottages, some brightly painted, others their original dull grey, are criss-crossed by narrow alleys festooned with colourful banners, Chinese lanterns and the odd bit of revolutionary zeal. It's a place of contrasts, reflecting China's past and future, and is as much home to locals as to foreign entrepreneurs, designers and tourists.
Inside the former 1920s commune, the smells of Thai noodles, Italian coffee and ginseng tea waft through the photo galleries, CD stores and boutiques. Symbols of the Great Leap Forward are mixed with modern iconography: hanging in a makeshift al fresco gallery, chisel-jawed communist soldiers are juxtaposed with KFC logos and the golden arches of McDonald's, and in a silk boutique figurines of Mao dressed in a green great coat are immersed in an aquarium with Chinese carp.

Seems it was kicked off by Aussies, with the Kommune cafe....
Kommune was the first Western restaurant to start up in Tian Zi Fang, opening to meet the  caffeine needs of a band of Australian expatriates.
Even the Australian Consul General, Tom Connor, has been along:
Visitors to the restaurant's weekly Great Aussie Barbecue have included the Australian consul general and the head of Qantas, and there are rumours an Australian ex-prime minister will don a Kommune apron in the coming months.
Access to the original article is by login, so I've dowloaded it to PDF file here.

Monday, 27 July 2009

Let the '12 Campaign Begin!

In the discussion last night between our pessimist and our optimist (see below on stocks and multiples), our interlocutors agreed on one thing: Obama is not doing well; he is too professorial, not power-wielding enough.  Not a Roosevelt or Johnson.   Both thought he would be "toast" in 2012.  Who are the candidates?  For the GOP, the front runners are, amazingly enough, Romney and Palin, a Mormon and an almost-born-again.  Let the campaign begin!  Actually, it won't be long until it starts--for some, maybe, like "slutty stewardess" Sarah-- it's started already.

I then came across this link to the All Seeing Eye, comparing the last twelve presidents' approval ratings at this point of their presidencies.  Obama's is tenth.  Harry Trumans was the lowest.  The two highest were Bill Clinton and Dubya.  Their approvals both had risen immediately after an impeachment and starting a war, leading a journalist to joke that if Obama can start a war and get impeached, his approval will go over 100%.  Links at the Eye, including a fun interactive chart of presidential approval ratings....

Jerusalem United

Apparently a UK Foreign Office Committee has recommended that Britain talk to "moderate" Hamas.  Rather like talking to "moderate" Nazis went one comment...

Led me to an article on East Jerusalem, which says it has never been Arab Jerusalem, save for a short period, 1948-67, when it was occupied by Jordan (and Jews expelled, synagogues burned).  The view -- eg within the BBC --  that Israel is "illegally" occupying East Jerusalem is simply not true.  The US Congress made this clear in 1995.

As Steve Lieblich, says 
The great obstacle to Middle East peace is not that Jews insist on living among Arabs. It is that Arabs insist that Jews not live among them.

Battery bicycles for Hong Kong!



I've been running a dilatory campaign -- perhaps that should read "walking" the campaign -- to have the Hong Kong government allow the use of battery assisted bicycles in Hong Kong (aka e-bikes).  The issue is that the Transport Regulations don't specifically cover e-bikes, so they simply lump them in with motorbikes, which require all sorts of safety gear, helmets and licensing, that just don't make sense for e-bikes.
Many jurisdictions simply deem them to be bicycles and allow people to use them as bikes.  In fact, that's right, because they are no faster (and in many cases are slower) than bicycles, on the flat and downhill.  They are just a bit easier to get uphill, but usually also need to pedal.
I wrote a submission to the government in May 2008, a copy of which is here.
Today's International Herald Tribune has an article, E-China, the bicycle kingdom is going electric (pdf version here): "...production of electric two-wheeler has soared from fewer than 200,000 eight years ago to 22 million last year...".
Maybe I should take it up again for Hong Kong.   A shame to be outdone, and out-flexibled by the Motherland.   I submitted my paper to the Transport Department and got back an anodyne response that simply repeated e-bikes were not covered by the Regulations and hence could not be licensed.  It didn't really address the suggestions I made, but I decided to simply keep riding mine and take the chance of arrest.... (so far, no such luck....).
*****************
Reference:
"Submission to Hong Kong Government, to legitimize the use of environmentally-friendly e-bikes in Hong Kong", Peter Forsythe, May 2008. Here.

S&P Multiples

 A comment last night (post below): that average multiples are now at or over pre-crisis levels, hence correction due.

This morning's Bloomberg happened to have a story on S&P Multiples:
  • Current level: 13 times earnings (I forget if this was trailing or forward, though if I recall, they're most often on forward earnings)
  • Average of last five decades: 16.5 times
  • If stocks were to increase in price to 16.5 times earnings, the market would need to go up 26%.....
Consensus estimates of the S&P, for what they're worth (and that may not be much...), is 1020 by year end, vs 979 now.

Short Stock, Long Stock?

Dinner last night at the Thai, two views on US and China's economic outlook.

The pessimist: 

The US hasn't seen the worst yet.  Unemployment rates, officially around 9%, are in reality much higher.  When those who are out of work, living on savings, run out of money and register for unemployment, the bread lines will start and the deficit blow out.  The period now is like that between 1929 and 1932, with see-sawing share prices, bi-polar investors, followed by nearly a decade of flat prices.   Share prices are at multiples above the pre-crisis levels, and due for correction.  The dollar will drop.

China: Guangdong is dire, factories shuttered and 15-50 million workers sent back to their villages. There's no buying power in the villages for them to set up viable city-oriented service industries.  But the government might pull off recovery with pump-priming, if it's targetted right.

Conclusion: short stocks, or stay out of them completely.  Long real estate: people always need somewhere to live.

The optimist: 

The crisis was one of lack of liquidity.  The underlying US economy had been fine until credit jammed up.  Now that liquidity is flowing again, orders are starting to flow and industry get back on its feet.  China, meantime, has many smart, energetic and committed politicians and bureacrats, focussed on getting China through the crisis and look to be making good progress. Inflation is a danger.

Conclusion: long stocks.  Neutral real estate.

Meeker's position (me): 

More in line with my hero, the Sage of Omaha: "it's hard to short the US in the long-term".  On China, the returned workers can pool money, energy and entrepreneurialism to grow new businesses.  

Conclusion: Hold stocks; stop-loss them; hold real estate.
=======================

ADDED (28 March 2025). 

Since July 2009 to 27 March 2025, the S&P500 index has risen from 1463 to 5693. That's 9.4% CAGR (Compound Annual Growth Rate). Which you won't find easily beaten elsewhere. Certainly not in real estate. 

In other words, I was wrong and "the pessimist" was wrong. The optimist on US stocks was right. 

The best way -- in this last 16 years -- was to be Long US Stocks. By my observation, to date, that has not ceased to be the case. Long US stocks. But some real estate for easy monthly income, as we have. 

Saturday, 25 July 2009

"Foreigners" in Hong Kong: shock, horror!

They featured my letter to the South China Morning Post today.
Read the letter in pdf version here.
I can't find the original article by Stephen Vines anywhere on the SCMP site, though the orginal article which started this exchange on 13 July is here.  
There's always a bit of xenophobia lurking in corners of China's bureaucracy.  Check out some comments on the Rio Tinto "spygate" issue, on 18 July, here.

Friday, 24 July 2009

Golfing, such a tough life


Going out this morning, as Jing was preparing for work, I found myself almost complaining that I "had" to play golf with Kevin... just that I'm such a klutz at the game.... then thought, "what on earth can I be complaining about, that I have to go out to play golf??!!".   A louring day, nicely tropical and sweat-drenching.  Above the view from the 14th hole of the Discovery Bay golf club, a lovely course on top of the hill behind our house, 27 tough holes.  I usually pick up on half the holes, refusing to let the game get in the way of a good walk...  This view is south-east over the South China Sea, the islands in the distance belong to China.  And as always, fun to yarn and yak with Kev....

Thursday, 23 July 2009

Watching the eclipse


Down to the Plaza yesterday to catch the eclipse over HK -- just 75% occluded, but I thought should be good, and was right -- perfect clear day and so relaxing down by Pacific Coffee, watching the moon, crisp and black, slide over the dark yellow sun.  Much longer than I thought, overall lasted from 08:15 to 10:32 (or thereabouts....)


Monday, 20 July 2009

Why the Battle of Tours

The Battle of Tours (732). Charles Martel vs Abdul Rahman. Martel was
victorious, driving back the Muslim invasions to Europe

13 May 2019: I’m kind of Archiving this.  I don’t want to delete it, but I’m changing the direction of the Blog and so I just want to put it somewhere that I can find it, because it’s part of my history with this blog, now nearly ten years old.  There’s also the fact I don’t want to be associated with the “far right’ folks that are identified by the “replacement theory”.  That I don’t buy into, although I recognise concerns, as senior Muslim leaders have specifically said they’re going to take over Europe with the “wombs of our women”.  So there’s that. But also maybe scare talk.  In any case, I don’t want that to be up front because I’m shifting to talk more about a book I’m writing.
I call this my "Personal Blog".  A place to keep articles and links to issues that interest me.  That's why I have no comment section.
I started it after 9/11, 2001, as I got interested in Islam. So it's mainly about Islam, but not exclusively.
I got interested in Islam because George W. Bush said it was a "Religion of Peace".  And I thought, funny, then why have 19 of its votaries attacked America?
I still remember  George W Bush cutting a fine figure in the rubble, saying that "these folks" (odd word, that, "folks"...) will not get away with it. We will hunt them down and they will pay. Fine fine....  It was then that W said what stuck in my mind "Islam is a religion of peace", he said.  So these people (these "folks") who have done this don't represent Islam.
Well, at that time, I'd had nothing much to do with Islam.  I'd travelled to many Islamic countries. Let's see: Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Malaysia, Indonesia.  And since to Sudan, Egypt, Ethiopia. But I'd not taken much notice of Islam as their religion.  Sure, the burkas in Afghanistan were a bit weird to a 24-year-old me.  But weird, not threatening.
And then 9-11.  And W Bush saying that the perpetrators -- who we pretty quickly knew were Muslim -- did not represent this "religion of peace".
So...  I thought I'd better have a closer look at this religion. To see how it was that a "religion of peace" could lead 19 men to hijack planes and slam them into skyscrapers all in the name of their religion of peace. ("I slam, Allah, I slam them for you")
So I bought Koran, Dawood's Penguin edition. And read it cover to cover. Which one can do pretty promptly because it's not long.  Not like the Bible.  It's less than the size of the New Testament, I'd reckon. And then I read the Hadith, the sayings and doings of Muhammad. And the Sirah, by Ibn Ishaq, which is the authorised biography of Muhammad.  I read them all.
Anyway, I can still remember that first reading of the Koran The hairs on the back of my neck stood up. I thought: if this is what we're dealing with, we've got a problem.
Because the Koran is pretty much cover to cover a manual for terrorism. It's no wonder, I thought, that those 19 did what they did. They were bound to do so if they were pious and believed that the Koran was the literal word of God, which they do.
(I still keep that Dawood copy of the Koran by my sofa-side.  I dip into it, at random, to see if I randomly come across a peaceable verse.  Nope.  It's pretty much horror, cover to cover.)
The more I read about Islam, the more concerned I got.  So I started to collect links and books.  All along I wanted to make sure that I read around the subject, not just the critical side, but the side that supports Islam.  That's led me to a library, now numbering in the 1000's with books on all sides of Islam, from Karen Armstrong to Richard Spencer.
But overall, one can't escape the conclusion that Islam is very problematic, to say the least.  The body of doctrine -- the Trinity of Koran, Hadith and the Sirah (the Life) of Muhammad -- is profoundly in contradiction to our traditions of freedom of speech, freedom of conscience, equality of women and minorities.  Of course not all Muslims are against the rights and freedoms of the west.  But the core ideology of Islam is. 
And then, I wanted somewhere to keep my research and links.
Hence this Blog.  As for the name of the Blog, well...
The Battle of Tours (October 732) was a battle between Frankish (Charles Martel) and Muslim (Abdul Rahman) forces near Poitiers and Tours in north-central France.  The Frankish forces were victorious.  Gibbon saw the battle as the high tide of Muslim advance into Europe and Leopold von Ranke as "the turning point of one of the most important epochs in the history of the world".
Many today see a similar battle -- for hearts and minds -- in the world today. 
Hence "The Battle of Tours."

********
I'm also posting on other bits and pieces that grab my interest, such as on China and Hong Kong, climate change, the war on drugs, and general miscellanea and ephemera.
I have not turned on “comments” setting, but I’m happy to have comments to my email, and I’ll ask you if I propose to post your comment.

This Page is an update of my earlier post on 18 August 2009.
19th March 2019: And a friend, an Occasional Reader of this blog, sent me this below, which strikes me as a pretty fair description of the Battle: